I made a promise yesterday that is going to be the hardest promise to keep. I made this promise after a dialogue with Palestinian students. This dialogue was a part of one of the sessions for the UNAOC. Being a part of that dialogue has left me stronger and weaker at the same time, and I am working on allowing the strength to grow bigger than the weakness.
We started the dialogue with the question, “How free are you to do what you want where you live?” For me, that question can be interpreted in many ways and the accessible amount of freedom anyone has in the United States is directly linked to race and class. Technically speaking, based on the interpretation of our constitution, we are all “free”. And that is simply true. If one has the money to get the resources to do what he or she wants to do, one can physically go out there and do it. No one will stop me from going to another state, having a road trip, packing my bags and going on vacation, or moving to another city. I am free to physically do anything I want to do and no one questions it. This does not factor in the struggles that many of us have in this country, the families living in projects, and the layers of deep rooted racism and classism that make this very freedom inaccessible. But, ideally speaking, if one has money and resources, one can do what he or she wants to do. It’s the freedom to have access to resources that is debatable.
So, how free am I to do what I want in the United States? I am very much free. I can verbally criticize my President. In Qatar, I was afraid to use Her Highness Sheikha Moza’s name out loud, just in case anyone heard me and I said something wrong. I am free to buy anything I want to buy as long as I have money. I am free to quit my job if I want to. I am free to write to the government to complain. Yet, in all of this, I don’t feel fully free. I feel trapped by my freedom. I truly believe that because we know we have freedom, we, as the youth in the States, trap ourselves in the idea of freedom, and live life through inaction. This ultimately isn’t living with freedom. We are living in the idea of freedom. And this was the most difficult concept to explain to the students in Gaza.
I felt the students in Gaza believed in my freedom intensely were begging me to take action. They truly believe in the American freedom and that we can do ANYTHING. They kept questioning why we, as Americans, don’t do more for Palestine. Why don’t we make our government change its mind? Why don’t we start a movement because we have the freedom in this country to physically do so? Why don’t we DO something? They don’t even have the freedom to buy basic text books for school. They do not have the basic freedom to pack their bags and go somewhere. They are physically trapped and listening to them begging for this basic freedom was a painful process to sit through. In that moment, I could not hold tears back, and I just had to look at my friend, and say, “We all do not care enough. And we do not know how” I sat there, on the winning team, feeling more powerless and helpless than ever. I didn’t know to explain the idea of apathy in the American culture. And I was sad. I am sad. I am disappointed. This is NOT about taking sides and being on the side for Palestine. My personal opinion on this topic has many layers. What I am writing about is raw, human, interaction with Palestinians. But the idea that apathy is so strong in our culture here, it does not matter what side I am talking about.
I cried through the entire second half of the dialogue. I sat there, with my heart fully open and open to the vulnerability in that moment. There was so much I could not properly explain about my story and my story seemed unreal compared to their stories. I get to wake up feeling safe. I do not have to think about safety. I am humbled by their love for life despite how little they have. They have very little but they love richly. Holding hands with the females there made me feel safer in this world. The love that us connected when we held hands brought inspiration back into my life. In the last few weeks, I have been trying to feel “alive” and I have been seeking that certain feeling. (The fact that I have to seek to feel alive is a totally different type of freedom and privilege.)
I was questioning every though during the dialogue. How do I explain that I have the freedom to write to my government, but that is all I have. There is no further movement that happens after the writing. How do I explain that I struggle with deciding what to be passionate about? People in my own motherland, India, are dying every day. What role does loyalty to my ethnicity play in this decision of passion? How do I explain that I am trying my best? I have given up a lot of people in my life because of my belief in the work that I do with World in Conversation? How do I explain that that every time I open my heart to their pain, it hurts so much, so then I close the door to my heart? Then I open it again when my strength is back. And then I get to a place of this helplessness that I need to close it again. I open and close my door to compassion because it hurts too much to recognize that I have the freedom to make changes but I really don’t. I have been granted the idea of freedom but not how to fully access it. I have recognized in this trip that my passion lies in healing humanity.
I am left humbled. One of the females, got up in the middle of the circle, and just hugged me. She apologized for making me cry. She was apologizing for asking the right to her humanity. That moment is lacking freedom. She didn’t feel fully free to express her pain and apologized. That hurt even more. I have realized how passionate I am about human pain and the healing that pain gives a chance to. And as painful as this dialogue was, it was even more healing, to all. In the end, we sat in a circle, holding hands. At this point, half the group was crying, including the facilitator. I left feeling so strong because of the power of dialogue and the power of compassion. And I also left feeling so weak in my tears.
One of the students came up to me afterwards and said, “Promise me you will always have the strength to the open the door when you close it.” I promised him. I will always make room for pain and healing.